How The Writers Sank An Over Ambitious ‘War 2’?

On paper this film had everything: a near Rs 400 crore production, two of India’s biggest stars — Hrithik Roshan and Jr NTR — backed by Kiara Advani, Anil Kapoor and Ashutosh Rana, and the marketing muscle of a major studio. It should have been a global blockbuster. Instead it collapsed under its own weight, and the fault lies squarely with the writers. The story is credited to Aditya Chopra, a name associated with some of Hindi cinema’s biggest commercial properties. The screenplay and execution were entrusted to Sridhar Raghavan (whose earlier work on big projects raised expectations) and dialogue by Abbas Tyrewala, a writer capable of sharp lines. Together they should have turned this star-studded canvas into a taut, emotional spectacle. Instead, overconfidence and sloppy plotting have produced a film that looks spectacular but feels hollow. Technically, the film often delivers: lavish set pieces, slick VFX and ambitious action set-pieces that scream big-budget cinema. But those production values only highlight the script’s failures. Characters are one-dimensional; motivations are perfunctory; scenes exist to justify action rather than to emerge from character. Even sequences that should thrill — aerial dogfights, tense confrontations — veer into the absurd and invite laughter instead of awe. This is not a failure of stars or resources but of storytelling. Aditya Chopra’s confidence in scale seems to have tipped into complacency: the belief that marquee names and massive budgets can substitute for a coherent story. What should have been a Rs 1,000 crore-level tentpole looks unlikely even to cross Rs 250 crore. This movie is a reminder: scale magnifies both strengths and weaknesses. No amount of star wattage, stunts or VFX can compensate for an unmoored script.