No Formal Adieu By SC Bar, Triple Whammy Judicial Scar!

One swallow does not make a summer! However, the Supreme Court Bar Association’s resolution against officially hosting the farewell party for retiring judge Bela M Trivedi immediately followed by protocol faux pas at Chief Justice of India BR Gavai’s felicitation function in Maharashtra, reinforces cited idiom while suggesting sharp fall of Indian judicial standards. The fact that the burning cash at Supreme Court justice Yashwant Verma’s residence hasn’t been translated into a FIR as yet, well after the Supreme Court sought report into the matter was submitted into apparent judicial cold storage has begun eroding judicial faith across India. Justice Bela Trivedi’s farewell was still attended by a full courtroom to include even the SCBA Chief Kapil Sibal, notwithstanding the resolution to deny her the formally due adieu. That Sibal chose to cite her lack of empathy when he sought it for a UAPA accused client couldn’t have been more out of place particularly in the wake of Pakistani terror that failingly sought to dampen public spirit through the Pahalgam attack upon innocent domestic tourists. Even CJI Gavai’s felicitation function not being attended by Maharashtra’s chief secretary and Mumbai’s police commissioner came like a double whammy for the judiciary being only the second Dalit justice to be appointed to the top post of the Apex Court. His late father RS Gavai was the founder of the Republican Party of India based out of Maharashtra emphasizing the Amedkarism doctrine against casteism in India. The two apparent instances of patriarchy and casteism were explained as actually being borne out due to Justice Trivedi’s judicial strictness and inadvertently missing in action (read absent) government officials at the CJI’s felicitation function. Will the burning cash case also be similarly brushed off? Now, that would be truly wishful thinking!